Defund the Police is the Right Demand, Policy Makers Should Take Note - Advancement Project - Advancement Project

Defund the Police is the Right Demand, Policy Makers Should Take Note

By Thomas Harvey, Justice Project Director

Former President Barack Obama recently made headlines when he called defund the police a “snappy slogan” and urged Black organizers to decide if they “actually want to get something done” or if they just “want to feel good among people you already agree with” during an interview with Peter Hamby on Snapchat’s “Good Luck America.”

Generally speaking, supporters of defund the police fall into two camps: those who want to reallocate bloated police budgets to social services or community programs and those who want to do that as a first step on the way to eliminating, or abolishing, the police altogether.  If you fall into the first camp, you may want to pay attention to what Barack Obama has to say.  If you fall into second, however, you need not waste your time.

Unlike “Hope and Change”, defund the police is a policy demand, not a “snappy slogan.” Abolitionist organizers saw decades of state sponsored racial policing violence and reforms that have not only consistently failed to stop that violence, but also further entrenched police power and reinforced the myth of their centrality to safety. Abolitionists know that the carceral state recalibrates to reproduce the same results, even following high-profile incidents of racist state violence.  For them, abolishing police, prisons, jails, and the entire network of public and private entities that comprise the prison industrial complex is the only rational response.

While invest-divest strategies have long been a tactic of abolitionist organizers, the murder of George Floyd elevated defund the police to the defining demand during a summer of rebellion that saw hundreds of thousands of people pour into the streets to fight back against racist, violent policing.  As they called for racial justice and a future where Black and Brown people are free and safe, the police responded with teargas, beatings, drones, and brutalization in more than 100 cities.  For them, defunding the police is a critical step toward abolition.

However, defund the police has a broader interpretation that can be interpreted as a compromise position.  For those who are either new to the fight or have evaluated the political realities as foreclosing the possibility of abolition, defund the police represents a more limited path to address the harms of policing. Having witnessed the police killing of Rayshard Brooks after he fell asleep in a Georgia restaurant drive-through, even those who are not yet abolitionists recognize that police are an ill-suited response to many situations. A still broader coalition of people recognize an urgent need to shift resources from police to other services.  Only the most ardent supporters of the police can look at city budgets and see 53% of money going to cops while .03% goes to services for the elderly and houseless and believe that is a just and effective way of spending a region’s money.

For this group of people, Obama’s analysis may seem more relevant.  He argues that defund the police risks losing “a big audience the minute you say it, which makes it a lot less likely you’re gonna get the change you want done.” Conversely, he embraces the logic behind invest-divest, suggesting that organizers “instead say let’s divest from the police department so everyone is being treated fairly.  You have to divert young people instead of getting into crime.  If there’s a homeless guy, maybe we send a mental health worker instead of an armed unit that might end up in tragedy.”

However, Obama’s arguments fail in at least two important ways:  1) many people already agree with the version of defunding the police he suggests; and 2) the American public has been consistently wrong on major racial and social justice issues.

According to a recent Gallup poll, 47% of people believe in reducing funding to police, including 70% of Black Americans, 49% of Hispanic Americans, and 41% of white Americans.  This group is not turned off by the idea of defunding the police; they embrace it.

Polling on racial justice issues shows how public opinion shifts even more clearly.  In 1968, Martin Luther King, Jr.  had a 75% disapproval rate. He was surveilled by the CIA and assassinated after pushing for a multiracial poor people's movement against capitalism. Today, he's at 90% approval.  Although it is taught in schools as one of the most important moments in Civil Rights history, the March on Washington was overwhelmingly disfavored by Americans in 1963.  60% of Americans polled believed the March on Washington was the wrong thing to do.  85% of Americans disliked protests for racial justice in general and believed demonstrations hurt the Civil Rights movement.

With that backdrop, why does current American opinion, or the opinion of one retired politician, significantly matter as we consider defunding the police?

When we think of the abolitionist racial justice work that Movement for Black Lives, Action St. Louis, Close the Workhouse, Michigan Liberation, Dream Defenders, the East Baton Rouge Parish Prison Reform Coalition and so many more have undertaken, the question isn't how does it poll today. The question is how do we support the modern day racial justice movement in all its forms.

Thomas Harvey

Thomas B. Harvey is the Justice Project Director at Advancement Project National Office, a next-generation, multi-racial civil rights organization. Rooted in the great human rights struggles for equality and justice, we exist to fulfill America’s promise of a caring, inclusive, and just democracy.


“Rest Easy, Baba”—Advancement Project Remembers Bob Moses

Yesterday, civil rights champion Bob Moses, a civil rights leader and crusader for social justice and education, passed away at the age of 86. 

Read More
Advancement Project National Office Applauds Introduction, Urges Passage of S. 1 to Protect Voting Rights of Communities of Color

MEDIA CONTACT Jeralyn Cave [email protected] 202-921-7321 WASHINGTON, DC – Today, the U.S. Senate introduced S. 1 – the For the People Act of 2021—a pro-democracy piece of legislation that aims to protect and strengthen access to voting, blunts the influence of dark money in politics and establishes anti-corruption measures for government. Advancement Project National Office, a 21st century civil rights and racial justice organization released the following statement. “Right now, at least 43 states have advanced legislation making it harder to vote on the heels of a historic election that saw record voter turnout,”…

Read More
Advancement Project National Office Condemns Atlanta Shooting and Racism, Violence Toward AAPI Community

MEDIA CONTACT Alex Jordan [email protected] WASHINGTON – This morning, in response to the shooting of eight people in Atlanta last night—six of whom were Asian American women—Advancement Project National Office’s Executive Director Judith Browne Dianis issued the following statement: “We extend our deepest sympathy to the family and friends of the individuals who were killed last night—and we express our solidarity with the Asian American and Pacific Islanders who have expressed righteous outrage and fear about this incident and the alarming spike in violence against Asian Americans over the last year. “This country has a long, sordid…

Read More
20 Ways Black People Made History in 2020

By Brittney Johnson, Communications Intern As we celebrate another Black History Month, we reflect on the milestones and accomplishments of Black Americans. From the ringing bells of Emancipation to the Civil Rights Movement, to the election of the first Black president, we continue to make history and move mountains despite the odds against us. For starters, 2020 was a tough year. Not only because of the COVID-19 pandemic, but also because of the multiple lives we lost to police brutality, social injustice and racial inequality. BUT, 2020 also brought many historic moments for the Black community as we pushed for…

Read More
STATEMENT: Osceola Sheriff’s deputy viciously assaults student, underscoring urgency in call for #PoliceFreeSchools

After a year of #PoliceFreeSchools wins in cities nationwide, Advancement Project National Office and Alliance for Educational Justice respond to recent #AssaultAtLiberty

Read More
Advancement Project National Office Issues Statement on President Biden’s Executive Orders Addressing Racial Equity

“We acknowledge and commend the Biden-Harris Administration’s efforts to make racial equality a legislative priority and center piece to their agenda."

Read More
Leading Civil Rights Groups Call on President Biden to Create White House Racial Equity and Inclusion Office

CONTACT Jessica Sarstedt Email: [email protected] WASHINGTON, DC—In the midst of the COVID-19 crisis, historic racial justice protests, and unprecedented commitment by the executive office to confront systemic racism, the Racial Equity Anchor Collaborative—the foremost diverse coalition of national racial justice and civil rights organizations representing and serving more than 53 million people in the U.S.—is pushing for racial equity to be at the forefront of government operations, policies and practices. The coalition calls on President Joe Biden to establish a White House Office on Racial Equity and Inclusion to coordinate the full range of federal agency…

Read More
Healing Communities of Color Beyond Wellness

By Flavia Jimenez, Managing Director of Organizational Development & Leadership We are our only relevant hope We are our only possible medicine –what is unveiled? the founding wound  by Adrienne Maree Brown When organizations discuss plans to address the impact that systemic racism and the violence of white supremacy have on staff, we often lack the language to openly discuss viable options. Perhaps it is because the wounds are too deep and too raw. Where do we even begin to bring a framework to folks who live and work with the pain? What do we do about…

Read More
Advancement Project National Office Applauds Nomination of Civil Rights Leaders to Biden-Harris U.S. Department of Justice

“Vanita Gupta and Kristen Clarke are formative civil rights leaders with decades of experience fighting discrimination, ensuring equity and safeguarding all Americans."

Read More